Will Bontrager
Home & Books • Stories • Amish Recipes • For Writers
Contact • About Will
Amish Cooking: Stories, Techniques, and Recipes

New Cocoa Candy

Delicious Extra Recipe Spun Out From Another

While testing and perfecting a chocolate-covered chocolate center recipe, one phase of the process made a delicious (not chocolate covered) candy. The recipe is below.
Twitter post link       Facebook post link

If you have read several pages at this recipe site, you undoubtedly are aware of the Amish chocolate-covered candy recipe book being put together. (Intended to be in time for the holidays, probably October.)

It takes a lot of testing and tasting. I want to get them as perfect as possible. (And like most people, I love taste-testing candy!)

And sometimes there is an extra benefit — an unanticipated new candy recipe separate from the one being tested.

So it was with Chocolate Sunflower Seed Clusters.

And now there's another one, Cocoa Candy.

Laying chickens

Here is the Cocoa Candy story. (The recipe follows.)

While talking to my sister, Anna, one day, I asked about chocolate centers for chocolate-covered candy. My thought was a chocolate center with a different color or taste than the chocolate coating. And perhaps also a different texture.

Here response was, "That would be interesting!"

Now, just so you know, Anna owned her Amish country store for many years. In the store, she sold her homemade Amish-recipe candy — including chocolate-covered candies.

With that kind of encouragement coming from that type of authority, I plunged into creating a chocolate center.

The first try was a mess.

My thought had been to blend cream cheese and baker's cocoa powder to get a chocolate of lighter color and different taste. Then add powdered sugar until the candy was firm enough to shape and dip.

The result was too chocolaty. And the cream cheese taste wasn't quite what I had expected. Also, it was too sweet; it took too much powdered sugar to firm the candy.

(When a chocolate lover declares something to be too chocolaty, you know something has got to change!)

For the next try, the cream cheese was dumped in favor of butter. And the amount of cocoa was halved.

It was good. Very good. Delicious, in fact. (It is the recipe you find a bit further down — certainly a winner.)

After it was chocolate-coated, however, the taste wasn't quite the same. The recipe needed a tweak. Then it became amazing enough for the upcoming book.

So now there are two recipes:

  1. There's the amazing chocolate-covered chocolate center recipe. That one is for the book.

  2. And there's the delicious Cocoa Candy recipe for eating without chocolate coating. The recipe is published in this article.

The delicious perfection of the Cocoa Candy was made even better with a small amount of sunflower seed kernels. In the recipe, that ingredient is listed as optional — for people who prefer not to have seeds in their candy.

Cocoa Candy

Here is the Cocoa Candy recipe.

Cocoa Candy

(Evolved in the author's kitchen.)

2 tablespoons butter

1 tablespoon cocoa

1 tablespoon sunflower seed kernels (optional)

1/2 cup powdered sugar

Cocoa Candy from Will Bontrager

Cream together the butter and cocoa until they are well blended.

If sunflower seed kernels are to be added, mix them in now.

Add the powdered sugar one or two tablespoons at a time. Blend well with each addition. (Be prepared to use a bit less or a bit more powdered sugar than the recipe calls for to end up with your desired consistency.)

Line a plate with wax paper or coat lightly with butter.

Shape the candy into bite-size pieces and place them on the plate. The shapes may be whatever you prefer — examples are balls, logs, squares, or a shape that makes you smile.

The Cocoa Candy is ready to eat.

If not eaten immediately, cover the candy to keep it from drying out. It may be refrigerated.

I have not tried finely crushed nuts in lieu of sunflower seed kernels. If you decide to give it a test, please use the comment section below and let us all know what you thought of the result.

As you can see, sometimes really good things happen when recipes are tested.

In this taste-testing process, an added bonus was this Cocoa Candy recipe that evolved from the chocolate-covered chocolate recipe. And as mentioned earlier, Chocolate Sunflower Seed Clusters was another good thing from testing previous flavors.

~ Did this inspire you? Raise a question? Stimulate something you wish to say? If yes, tap here and put it in the public comment area.

Be notified whenever a new story, recipe, or technique is posted.

Enter your email address here.

Submit Notification Request
Twitter post link       Facebook post link

Your Comments, Questions, and Opinions

[comments to come]
Twitter post link       Facebook post link
Chamber of Commerce - on the Web logo